50 Holiday Gifts We Love From Etsy


The Everymom’s product selections are curated by the editorial team. If you buy something through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no cost to you. We only recommend products we genuinely love.

Graphic by: Anna Wissler
Graphic by: Anna Wissler

Once upon a career, I owned a small Etsy shop selling homemade dollies. I remember feeling so excited every time I got an order and incredibly touched that my creations were making a difference in someone’s life. Every time I receive a product from an Etsy shop owner, it usually comes with a handwritten note and sincere gratitude. Plus, the handcrafted items are always so special and stay in my home for years. Etsy gifts are a win-win for everyone!

This year, I knew I’d do a lot of my holiday gift shopping on Etsy. There’s nothing better than supporting a small business, especially on the annual Small Business Saturday. But Etsy is a huge space, and it takes time to sort through all the finds!

Luckily, we’ve curated our favorite Etsy gifts just for you. From toys and accessories for kids to gifts for friends, each piece gets our editor’s stamp of approval. Be sure to purchase soon, because so many of these items are personalized so they take a little extra time to create. Scroll down to shop our favorite items! 

Our Favorite Etsy Gifts for 2023

For Kids

Etsy has no shortage of special gifts for kids, including gift ideas that aren’t toys like personalized decor for their rooms, storage spaces for their trinkets, and books they’ll cherish for years. Of course, they have plenty of unique toys, too. Keep reading for over 20 of our favorite Etsy gifts for kids this year.

A Button and a Stitch
Handmade Princess Ballerina Doll

This adorable doll with Nutcracker vibes is perfect for everything from pretend play to festive bookshelf decor.

Shop now
Personalized Toddler Tool Belt

This handmade tool belt set can be personalized for the handy toddler on your list.

Shop now
Personalized Bedtime Storybook

Make little ones the star of their very own bedtime story with this personalized book.

Shop now
Personalized Pajamas

What better way to celebrate the season than with a pair of holiday-themed pajamas? These can be customized with the name or monogram of your little one and come in pink or blue.

Shop now
Eventide Pennant Co
Name Pennant

A fun addition to a kid’s bedroom or play space, this name pennant can be customized with tons of color combos.

Shop now
Personalized Name Nightlight

A personalized nursery night light is as cute as it is functional. This one has multiple options for the style—from stars and clouds to moons and mountains.

Shop now
Custom Silicone Sippy Cup

Our little ones want to have their own cup and straw sets with personality just like we do, and this silicone one is great for preventing spills and creating soft landings.

Shop now
Shop Little Joy Co
Highchair Toy

The reviews of this toy could speak for themselves, but we too can’t get enough of its appealing, functional, and innovative design. This stimulating high chair toy is sure to encourage sensory exploration and fine motor skill development.

Shop now
Busy Puzzle
Personalized Busy Board

A team favorite, this personalized puzzle and busy board is both a charming keepsake and developmentally-engaging toy. Customize the colors, shapes, and more!

Shop now
Domestic Objects
Canvas Playhouse

Easy to construct and bound to inspire hours of exciting, imaginative play, this canvas playhouse has four windows and an open front door. Multiple colors available.

Shop now
GCR Wooden Creations
Sensory Table

Perfect to spruce up the play area and awaken the little one’s imagination.

Shop now
Tree Sounds
Transformable Climber

Keep little ones active indoors with this Montessori-inspired triangle climber with ramp. Buy together or separately.

Shop now
Craft Carve
Personalized Stool

These artfully crafted name puzzle stools are not only customizable with your child’s name, but they also have cutouts on the sides that can be shaped like a whale, a butterfly, and more.

Shop now
Berwick Blooming Buds
Sherpa Snowman Pillow

Another festive plush gift that’s perfect for seasonal decor or winter (indoor) play.

Shop now
Art 2 the Extreme
Recycled Name Crayons

Made with recycled crayons, these personalized name crayons are a special stocking-sized gift.

Shop now
PS Stitching
Crewneck Monogrammed Sweatshirt

Chain stitch embroidery makes these custom sweatshirts extra special. Available in multiple colors and sizes 2T – 7.

Shop now
The Swoon Paper Co
Personalized Star Wars Notepad

For the kid who’s feeling “the force,” this personalized notepad is great for lists, notes, or drawing fun!

Shop now
Custom Neon Wonderland
Neon Name Sign

Made to look like a vintage neon sign, this custom wall art is perfect for tween and teen bedroom decor.

Shop now
Don’t Forget the Gift
Personalized Menorah for Kids

Make sure to gift this menorah on the first night so you can light it during the rest of Hanukkah. Available for multiple children (pictured here) or a single child.

Shop now
Blossom and Pear
Personalized Ballerina Musical Carousel

They’ll not only cherish this classic, heirloom-style musical carousel, but they’ll be able to pass onto their own kids one day, too.

Shop now
Kustom Kreashions
Personalized Ballerina Jewelry Box

A cute keepsake for all their treasures, this ballerina music jewelry box comes in multiple colors and can be personalized.

Shop now
Le Rose Gifts
Personalized Duffel Bag

Whether used for sleepovers, trips to the grandparents’ house, summer camp, or family vacation, you can never go wrong with an adorable, personalized duffle bag.

Shop now
Little Hands and Nature
Kids’ Potion Kit

For the kid who’s always asking to make science experiments or potions, grab this cute sensory gift set. Holiday-themed potions also available.

Shop now
Snazzie Bombs
Snowman Bath Bombs

Already a popular reader pick from our Stocking Stuffers gift guide, these adorable mini snowmen make bath time more fun and festive! Sold in packs of 1 to 20.

Shop now

For Adults

From personalized picks to festive apparel to unique items for home, this list of the best Etsy gifts for adults is full of picks sure to be favorites this year.

Natural Canvas Laptop Sleeve

This pretty zippered sleeve keeps laptops safe and can also store pens and paper. Three colors available.

Shop now
Diamond Tee Design
Holiday Sweatshirt

There is no better way to celebrate the holidays than with a Christmas-themed sweatshirt, and this one is fun and festive!

Shop now
Sweet Water Decor
Candle Care Set

For the candle-obsessed, gift this candle care set with a snuffer, wick trimmer, and more.

Shop now
Holmes Soy Candle
Spruce Soy Candle

Blue spruce is one of the best holiday scents, and this candle is sure to fill your home with the smell of a winter wonderland. With notes of cinnamon and cedar, it’s sure to make you feel extra cozy.

Shop now
On Off Accessories
Gold Minimalist Hair Claw Clip

Grab this pretty gold hair clip, perfect for holiday happenings or for a touch of glamour.

Shop now
Caitlyn Minimalist
Off-Center Initial Necklace

Personalize this gold necklace with their name, intials, or their kids’ initials for a special custom gift.

Shop now
Danique Jewelry
Minimalist Birthstone Bracelet

These pretty minimalist birthstone bracelets come with up to six gems per bracelet, so they are perfect for everyone from a new mom to a grandmother. Plus, their dainty size means you can layer together if more children or grandkids arrive.

Shop now
The Fro Experts
Rice Water Leave-In Conditioner

Right on time for dry strand season, gift this creamy leave-in conditioner treatment with organic fermented rice water, aloe vera, and essential oils.

Shop now
Hanukkah Sweatshirt

Celebrate Hanukkah in style with this adorable sweatshirt, which features all the best food of the season! Three colors available.

Shop now
Wunder Party
Meet Me at Midnight Slippers

2023 was the year of The Eras Tour and this clever and cozy gift is perfect for the Swifty in your life.

Shop now
Zehr Custom Engraving
Initial Iced Coffee Glass

Unlike many of the cute iced coffee cups you find on Etsy, this one is laser-engraved so it’s dishwasher safe—and a gorgeous personalized gift!

Shop now
Storied Creatives
Dream House Diorama Ornament

Barbie fans–including her fanbase’s resurgence with the recent movie release–will love this diorama ornament of her dream house. Check out other pop culture faves by this seller too! Ornament available in multiple colors.

Shop now
Morning Joy Co.
Personalized Recipe Cutting Board

What better way to always have someone’s signature recipe on hand—in their own handwriting—than to have it laser carved into a keepsake serving board?

Shop now
Shop Among the Flowers
Body + Bath Meditation Oil

Crafted from powerful botanical ingredients like arnica infused oil, copaiba essential oil, and lavender essential oil, these meditation oils are intended to rejuvenate and repair.

Shop now
Quilted Floral Coat

From grocery store runs to school pick-up and drop-off, they will be able to wear this quilted floral piece anywhere.

Shop now
Black Butterfly Signs
Personalized Doormat

Make your doorway truly your own with this customizable doormat. Printed with long-lasting ink on coir, these mats are designed to last for years to come.

Shop now
Circle and Square Decor
Personalized Acrylic Family Calendar

Looking to get organized for the new year? Look no further than this large acrylic dry-erase calendar. Personalized just for your family, this piece is sure to last you for years.

Shop now
Custom House Drawing

This hand-drawn home artwork is sure to become a sentimental keepsake.

Shop now
Luma and Co Shop
Hand Blown Glass Aston Candle Holder

Elevate the look of any candle with this gorgeous hand-blown glass cloche.

Shop now
Create Gift Love
Personalized Leather Photo Keychain

A reader favorite from our Father’s Day gift guide, this sentimental key chain is perfect for dads, grandparents, or anyone who’d love a cute photo to look at daily.

Shop now
Riverry Studio
Watercolor Pet Portrait

Gift a custom portrait of the furry family members, like this adorable custom water color. Single pet portraits also available.

Shop now
Paper Anniversary Love
Custom Leather Tray With Kids’ Drawings

A heartwarming keepsake made out of genuine leather. Whether your child’s creation is a drawing or scribbles, they won’t discriminate for the engraving process.

Shop now
By Page
Personalized Leather Dopp Kit

Men deserve a nice spot for their toiletries too. And this dopp kit can be personalized with their initials.

Shop now
Branches Design Co.
Personalized Golf Tees

For the golfer in your life, personalize a set of golf tees with their name or a special message so they’ll think of you when they hit the links!

Shop now
Swanky Badger
Personalized Decanter Set

Gift the whiskey connoisseur in your life this personalized decanter and tumbler set to up his/her happy hour game.

Shop now
Rare Upcycle
Steel Firewood Rack

To hold firewood in style for an indoor fireplace, this steel rack makes for a wonderful and decorative-yet-functional piece.

Shop now

Did you check your list twice and realize you still have more people to shop for? We’ve got you covered! Check out our entire holiday gift guide for even more ideas.

shop best holiday gifts