24 Holiday Gifts We Love From Etsy

The Everymom’s product selections are curated by the editorial team. If you buy something through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no cost to you. We only recommend products we genuinely love.

etsy holiday gifts
Graphics by: Kathie Baptista

Once upon a career, I owned a small Etsy shop selling homemade dollies. I remember feeling so excited every time I got an order and incredibly touched that my creations were making a difference in someone’s life. Every time I receive a product from an Etsy shop owner, it usually comes with a handwritten note and sincere gratitude. Plus, the handcrafted items are always so special and stay in my home for years. Win-win for everyone!

This year, I knew I’d do a lot of my holiday gift shopping on Etsy. There’s nothing better than supporting a small business, especially during such a tough time for owners. But Etsy is a huge space, and it takes time to sort through all the finds!

Luckily, we’ve curated our favorite Etsy gifts just for you. From toys and accessories for kids to gifts for friends, each piece gets our editor’s stamp of approval. But purchase soon, because shipping delays are bound to be troublesome this year. Scroll down to shop our favorite items! 


For Kids

Busy Puzzle

Personalized Name Puzzle

Handcrafted from birch plywood, these Montessori-inspired name puzzles will not only teach your little one letter and spacial recognition but will also become one of their most beloved toys.


Handmade Rag Doll

This adorable hand-stitched rag doll wears her hair in Bantu knots and has a dress constructed out of 100% cotton African wax print. You can even choose whether she wears a hair clip or a headband.

etsy gifts
Glitter Party Co.

Colorful Holiday Ball Garland

Is your little one enraptured by the Land of Sweets in the second act of the Nutcracker? This felt ball garland will make them feel like they're among the sugar plums.

Twenty-Seven UK

Personalized Pull Along Wooden Crocodile

Customize the wheels of this pull-along crocodile toy with your little one's name and birth date. This is sure to be a favorite keepsake for years to come.

LL Crayon Creations

Personalized Name Crayons

These customizable name crayons come in an adorable Hanukkah-themed box, making them a thoughtful gift for little ones who are learning the traditions of the holiday.

etsy gifts
Copper and Brass Paper

Black Mermaid Notebook

A celebration of the history of Black mermaids in Caribbean and African folklore, this beautifully illustrated journal is meant to house all sorts of ideas and stories.

Craft Carve

Personalized Puzzle Stool

These artfully crafted name puzzle stools are not only customizable with your child's name, but they also have cutouts on the sides that can be cut into a whale, a butterfly, and more.

name light
Neekye Custom Light

Neon Name Sign

Made to look like a vintage neon sign, this custom wall art is perfect for tween and teen bedroom decor.

Domestic Objects

Canvas Playhouse

Easy to construct and bound to inspire hours of exciting, imaginative play, this canvas playhouse has four windows and an open front door.

Multiple colors available

Natural Wood Goods Shop

Rainbow Climbing Arch

Perfect for climbing and crawling and featuring beautiful pastel shades of blue, pink, purple, and green, this Montessori-inspired wooden arch is sure to be a blast for any active little one.

kids holiday pajamas
Marie Company

Kids Personalized Christmas Pajamas

What better way to celebrate the holiday season than with a pair of Christmas-themed pajamas? These can be customized with the name of your little one and come in red or green.



For Grown-Ups


Festive Christmas T-Shirt

We love how this sweet graphic T-shirt celebrates the little joys of the holiday season, from hot chocolate to gingerbread cookies.

Multiple colors available


Personalized Name Bracelet

Stackable gold beaded bracelets are super stylish these days, and these custom ones feature adorable lettering. Spell out a name or initials on this cute keepsake.

Etsy gifts

Leather Airtag Keychain

Perhaps the best practical gift of the year, Air Tags were made for the person who's always losing their keys. This leather keychain comes in multiple colors and can be monogrammed.

Six Oaks & Co.

Plaid Face Mask

Stylish meets practical with this plaid face mask, which comes in a festive red and green print. Stay safe with this mask's adjustable ear beads.

Bridesmaid Forever

Personalized Family Ornament

Personalize these Christmas ornaments with up to six family members and pets. With hundreds of hairstyle and pet options to choose from, this ornament will be an accurate portrait of your family.

etsy gifts
Shop Among the Flowers

Body + Bath Meditation Oil

Crafted from powerful botanical ingredients like arnica infused oil, copaiba essential oil, and lavender essential oil, these meditation oils are intended to rejuvenate and repair.

The Fro Experts

Organic Hair Tea Rinse

To treat hair loss or scalp irritation, look no further than this weekly organic tea hair rinse. Made of lavender, moringa, jasmine, peppermint, and more, this rinse smells amazing.


Festive Hanukkah T-Shirt

Celebrate Hanukkah in style with this adorable graphic T-shirt, which features all of the best little things about the magical eight nights.

Multiple colors available

Peppy Mack

Christmas Trees Sweatshirt

There is no better way to celebrate the holiday season than with a Christmas-themed sweatshirt, and this one has an adorable tree print.

Multiple colors available

Holmes Soy Candles

Spruce Soy Candle

Blue spruce is one of the best holiday scents, and this candle is sure to fill your home with the smell of a winter wonderland. With notes of cinnamon and cedar, it is sure to make you feel extra cozy.


Personalized Keychain

A reader-favorite from our Father's Day gift guide, this sentimental key chain is perfect for dads, grandparents, or anyone who'd love a cute photo to look at daily.

Black Butterfly Signs

Personalized Doormat

Make your doorway truly your own with this customizable doormat. Printed with long-lasting ink on coir, these mats are designed to last for years to come.

Circle And Square Decor

Large Acrylic Calendar

Looking to get organized for the new year? Look no further than this large acrylic dry-erase calendar. Personalized just for your family, this piece is sure to last you for years.


This article was originally published in December 2020. It has been updated for timeliness.

Shop Our Full 2021 Holiday Gift Guide
with even more Etsy picks!
Shop Now