Our Favorite Personalized New Baby Gifts From Etsy

The Everymom’s product selections are curated by the editorial team. If you buy something through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no cost to you. We only recommend products we genuinely love.

New baby gifts are fun to pick out, but it can be hard to know just what to get. The baby gift you can’t go wrong with is anything personalized. Adding a monogram, name, baby stats, or other personalization to the gift gives it a little something extra. And it’s likely not something mom or baby already has.

With so many adorable and special options to choose from, we’re helping you pick out the perfect new baby gift with some of our favorites below. Read on to check out 20+ of our favorite personalized new baby gifts—for mom and the baby—from Etsy.


Gifts for the New Baby

Etsy | Busy Puzzle

Personalized Name Puzzle

We love that you can select whatever colors and letters you want for this personalized puzzle that kids can enjoy through their early years.

Etsy | Love My Baby X

Personalized Baby Teether

Useful and cute, this personalized baby teether is made of food-grade silicone and natural wood, and it comes in nine colors.

personalized rainbow stacker
Etsy | Matrena Toys

Personalized Wooden Rainbow Stacker

This Montessori favorite wooden rainbow stacking toy comes in three color assortments and is even more special thanks to the personalization.

Etsy | The Preppy Pair

Monogrammed Kids' Toiletry Bag

A monogrammed toiletry bag to stash diapers, creams, toys, snacks, and all the other baby/kid necessities in is a must-have for any new mom.

Etsy | Glitzby

Personalized New Baby Wood Block

A personalized two-by-two inch wooden block with baby's initial, full name, birth weight, and details adds a special touch to nursery decor.

Etsy | Livi Lou Designs

Custom Baby Illustration

A custom baby illustration is a super special addition to a nursery.

Etsy | Busy Puzzle

Personalized Baby Name Puzzle

Personalized name puzzles are another option you can't go wrong with. This one comes in different colors and themes.

Etsy | A Dose of Pretty

Personalized Name Train

A classic that everyone loves is a personalized name train for baby's shelf, which they can play with when they're older.

Etsy | DLight Gifts

Personalized Nursery Lamp

A personalized nursery night light is as cute as it is functional. This one has multiple options for the style, including a custom illustration.

Etsy | Sweet Berry Lane Shop

Personalized Superhero Puzzle

While new babies won't be playing with puzzles anytime soon, you can put it in a frame for nursery decor until they're ready to have fun with it.

Etsy | Funky Monkey Children

Monogrammed Baby Ruffle Blanket

A simple, monogrammed baby blanket in whatever color you choose is not only useful but can also be a great keepsake too.

Etsy | U Think It Nina Make It

Monogrammed Hooded Baby Towel

Babies grow out of the kid-sized towels so quickly, and that's why we love this full-sized hooded towel that you can personalize with a name, monogram, and whatever embroidery you choose.

Etsy | Emmiebel Studio

Monogrammed Baby Blanket

Is there anything better than a super soft blanket to snuggle a newborn with? The reverse of this monogrammed baby blanket is equally soft and comes in different print options.

Etsy | Craft Carve

Personalized Name Puzzle Step Stool

Before you know it, new babies are toddlers and preschoolers who need step stools to brush their teeth and wash their hands, so this gift is both practical and thoughtful.

personalized Etsy gifts growth chart
Etsy | Downright Creative

Family Growth Chart

A family growth chart is a special and useful keepsake. Not only is it portable (in case the family moves homes), it can also be personalized with the baby's name or the family name.

Etsy | Embellish Monograms

Monogrammed Bunny Stuffed Animal

A new baby can never have too many stuffed animals, right? Adding a monogram to this stuffed bunny's ear is a special touch to go the extra mile.

Etsy | Step Stitches

Personalized Raggedy Ann Doll

This Raggedy Ann doll comes in various skin tones, and you can personalize it with a name embroidered on the dress. It is also available as a Raggedy Andy doll.

Etsy | Letterfest

Personalized Sweet Dreams Storybook

Personalized books are a fun way to engage little ones and get them to love reading early.

Etsy | Letterfest

Personalized Unicorn Storybook

A personalized book makes your child the main character of their own storybook for special memories that will last well beyond childhood.


 Gifts for Mom

Etsy | SunStori

Personalized Name Bracelet

These bracelets are the perfect everyday layering piece. Both high quality and sturdy, you truly can't beat the price on this thoughtful gift if you're looking for something special that won't break the bank.

Etsy | Label With Love

Customized New Mom Wine Labels

For the wine lover in your life, these custom new mom milestone labels add a fun and thoughtful touch to some of the everyday celebrations new moms go through, like the first date night without baby or first night out with the girls. Customize with the new mom's first name and baby's birth year, along with the label border and background colors.

Etsy | Blushes And Gold

Initial Bar Necklace

You can add a name, a birthdate, or initials to this engraved bar necklace to give a new mom something she can wear every day.

Etsy | Danique Jewelry

Birthstone Bracelet

A birthstone bracelet with mom and baby's birthstones is another thoughtful way to shower someone with some new mom love. These bracelets come with up to six gems per bracelet, so they're perfect for a new mom or a mom of multiples. Their dainty size also makes them perfect to layer together if more children arrive down the line.

Etsy | The White Invite Gifts

Personalized Tumbler

New moms have a lot on their minds, and staying hydrated is important (especially for breastfeeding moms), but with so much time and attention going to the baby, it can be hard.

personalized ring
Etsy | Kathryn Riechert

Personalized Name Ring

This dainty stackable name ring is something a new mom can wear daily and add to her collection if she decides to have more kids down the line.

Etsy | Danique Trends

Mama Necklace

She'll cherish this dainty, gold-plated, and on-trend 'mama' necklace forever.

initial necklace
Etsy | Caitlyn Minimalist

Custom Initial Necklace

An initial necklace is great for new moms to layer with other jewelry and to celebrate the birth of their little one.

Customize the length and finish—sterling silver, 18K gold, and rose gold.

personalized gift for mom
Etsy | Melsys Illustrations

Customized Card

Customize the hair and skin color of mom and baby as well as the clothing color for a frame-worthy personalized card.

10 Gifts for New Moms That Have Nothing To Do With the Baby
Read More